Over the last few weeks, a number of prominent Republicans have come out in favor of making the birth control pill available over the counter. This action has the support of the American Society of Obstetric and Gynecology. It would almost certainly bring prices down and obviate the need for women to make an expensive visit to the OB/Gyn to get birth control. It wouldn’t end the Culture War, but it would turn down the heat a bit.
There are reasons to be concerned: the “standard” pill isn’t appropriate for everyone and the wrong prescription can create serious health problems (a friend of mine developed a pulmonary embolism because of a bad scrip). But opposition is also coming from an unexpected source: Planned Parenthood.
Planned Parenthood opposes over-the-counter contraception, pushing back against a popular Republican argument being used in many Senate races this year.
The nonprofit’s lobbying arm, which advocates for women’s reproductive health issues, argued that calls for allowing birth control pills to be sold without a prescription are “empty gestures.”
The policy change would “force women to go back to the days when they paid out of pocket for birth control — which can cost upwards of $600 a year,” Planned Parenthood Action Fund wrote on its website.
As has been pointed out, there are stores that sell birth control bills for as little as $10-20 a month. Furthermore, there is no power on Earth that can stop an insurer from covering birth control even if it is over-the-counter. In fact, there’s no reason the birth control mandate can not include reimbursement for OTC birth control (said mandate having been upheld for all but religious organizations and closely-held corporations). Going even further, the contraception mandate was justified by its supporters because some women need very specialized birth control or IUD devices. These would not be available over-the-counter as Planned Parenthood notes in their own statement. Nothing in this would destroy the Obamacare mandate. Nothing in this would stop women from getting birth control. All it would do is change how they get it.
Then there’s this gem:
The statement also noted that no prescription drug manufacturer has applied for their pills to be made available over the counter.
As one of my Twitter followers noted, spot the paradox! We can’t make it available over the counter because no one is asking for permission to sell over the counter this thing they legally can’t sell over the counter.
Of course, I’m sure this has nothing to do with Planned Parenthood themselves being a vendor of reproductive services and prescription birth control. Nothing whatsoever. And I’m sure it has nothing to do with the money they get from the federal government and state governments to provide birth control to poor women. And I’m sure it has nothing to do with their political arm wanting to maintain a “war on women” to raise money and campaign against Republicans. God forbid we should defuse that particular line of crap.
It’s funny. Planned Parenthood is an organization I agree with on a number of issues. But the way they approach the issues fills me with revulsion. They are stewed in Culture War rhetoric and a deep hatred of everything Republican. In this case, it has massively warped their vision. Making birth control available over the counter would do a lot to increase women’s access (especially for those who are uninsured). Planned Parenthood’s position is that they oppose it because REPUBLICANS.
If there’s a War on Women, Planned Parenthood is shooting at their own side.