The Government is merely a servant -- merely a temporary servant; it cannot be its prerogative to determine what is right and what is wrong, and decide who is a patriot and who isn't. Its function is to obey orders, not originate them. - Mark Twain
Now this should be an interesting case to watch, because it concerns issues that are very current and controversial in this country but it’s taking place in the UK.
A teenage schoolgirl will appeal to the High Court on Friday to overturn a ban on her wearing a “purity ring” at school to symbolize her decision to abstain from sex before marriage.
Lydia Playfoot, 16, from West Sussex, says the silver ring is an expression of her faith and should be exempt from the school’s rules on wearing jewellery.
“It is really important to me because in the Bible it says we should do this,” she told BBC radio. “Muslims are allowed to wear headscarves and other faiths can wear bangles and other types of jewellery. It feels like Christians are being discriminated against.”
Playfoot’s lawyers will argue that her right to express religious belief is upheld by the Human Rights Act.
This one should be fun to watch. I wonder, when she’s 17 and has a screaming kid, will the generous British welfare system still have to pay for it?
Posted by
Lee on 06/25/07 at 01:18 PM (
Discuss this in the forums)
Comments
Commenting is not available in this weblog entry.
<< Back to main
I am in two minds about this.
Firstly, there is the line that the school should be able to decide the uniform. I went to a school where we had a strict uniform, but they did make exceptions for people for certain religious things, e.g. a seek guy’s bracelet. Still, it was just a non issue.
Then there is the line that kids should be able to express themselves and wearing a ring is pretty non offensive.
The problem is should a religious belief be considered relevant to whether that person should be able to circumvent the school’s policy, and for that I would say no. It should make no difference if the kid wants to wear the ring because they are a Christian or because they think wearing the ring will make it more likely aliens might choose her to come to their spaceship.
But how you setup a law to allow that I don’t know, and where you draw the line I don’t know either.