The Palestinian Push

The Palestinian Authority is pushing for recognition as a full state by the UN. They are a few votes shy of forcing the US to either accept it or veto it.

While I support the existence of a Palestinian state, eventually, I think full statehood is a bad idea, partly for reasons outlined by Fareed Zakaria:

At the end of the day, there is only one way you’re going to get a Palestinian state. And that’s if the Israelis agree to it. They have the land; they have the guns; they have the money. Palestinians may regard it as deeply unfair, and I understand that. But it is the world that we live in. The only way they’re going to get a Palestinian state is to engage directly with the Israelis.

And the only way they are going to engage with the Israelis is to get control of their own damn country, especially Gaza. Israel can not put up with being rocketed on a periodic basis. The push for full statehood is mostly a push to further isolate Israel, rather than work with them.

And that’s the key point here. The Palestinians have basically ignored every olive branch for the last 90 years. And, for all their rhetoric, the Arab nations don’t really want a Palestinian nation either. Jordan and Egypt happily occupied and oppressed areas that were supposed to be Palestinian and much of the territory that is supposed to be Palestine is still owned by Jordan, who haven’t even hinted at complying the UN mandate of … 1948. This isn’t really about a Palestinian state, which could have been created anytime in the last six decades. This is about cutting out Israel. This is about the Palestinian Authority getting their country without having to abandon their genocidal intentions.

Obama, to his credit, is siding with Israel. The indications are that he will either call for a year long “study” to delay things or veto it. France is playing their usual “the dog at my homework” game and supporting giving non-member state status. Britain seems likely to align with us. And everyone is trying to make sure this doesn’t come to a head in the Security Council.

We’ll see what happens. I haven’t been happy with Israel’s behavior lately. And at least part of the reason previous deals failed was because Ehud Barak and Ehud Olmert were undermined by their own government. But we can’t agree to this transparent ploy to create a nation that is effectively at war with an ally. Thankfully, our Administration understands that.

Comments are closed.

  1. blameme

    Palestine, please don’t call for statehood now.

    That’s it? Just don’t ask for statehood? How about they stop lobbing missiles into neighborhoods, using civilians as human shields and firing rockets from residences, digging tunnels to kidnap and murder innocents and not elect f*cking terrorists to run the government?


    Thumb up 6

  2. AlexInCT

    Actually if they have a state and Israel is attacked from it, is that an excuse to go to war and finally do whatever it takes to stop these monsters?

    Thumb up 8

  3. Kimpost

    Well, those too, along with “Israel, please end the occupation already”. But I settled for just two very linked issues. Both less complicated than the full peace process…

    Thumb up 0

  4. CzarChasm

    I had the chance to watch/listen to Netanyahu’s whole speech today. I’d defy anyone to listen to that whole speech and try to say that Israel hasn’t done everything it can possibly do without just packing up everything and moving somewhere else in order to find a solution. What has Abass/PA done? According to Bibi, nothing, zip, zero, nada. I’d accept that Bibi’s version is some degree of exaggeration, but there were so many line-items that he checked off that are a matter of historical record that show the PA as wanting anything but peace, that to say that they (the PA) deserve statehood without having to even negotiate with Israel is the same as saying that Israel has no right to exist.

    Whatever, it was a great speech. If you can find it, listen to it.


    Thumb up 1

View Mobile Site